Page 1 of 2

Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-09-30 14:33
by makh
A tabbed or expandable button in signature to show:

each Debian users' (say):

1. Hardware via inxi or otherwise
2. Apps by repo
3. Apps by non repo (debian, compiled)
4. Apps on wine
5. Debian version
6. etc (only important stuff) :)

It shall be less than 100kb, say if 1000 fill it, total will be less than 100mb on forum server. :idea:

It may tend to promote the adaptability of Debian, and its success :!:

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-02 18:29
by phenest
And who's going to code it, and integrate it into the forum?

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-02 19:03
by ComputerBob
IMO, those who feel like sharing that type of information in their signatures already do it, without any need for it to be coded into the forum.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-03 01:04
by makh
phenest wrote:And who's going to code it, and integrate it into the forum?
Using open source tools, its not a rocket science OR is it :?: It shouldn't take much time. 8)

b) Well the team who got it from Lenney to Squeeze. :!:
ComputerBob wrote:IMO, those who feel like sharing that type of information in their signatures already do it, without any need for it to be coded into the forum.
Well kindly cross-check: there is a limit, just had to push it in (e.g. Can you put inxi -F there :?: ). :) And really wanted to add more. The information must be resourceful, understandable, and of-course opensource :| . After all, it is claimed that Debian is a Universal OS, proof comes from USER EXPERIENCES/CLAIMS. :)

2. Purpose is: simply it shall be of help to new entrants in debian/linux or some already existing. :idea:

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-03 01:50
by craigevil
Debian HCL; Debian GNU/Linux device driver check & report - http://kmuto.jp/debian/hcl/

Home Page - Linux Hardware Compatibility List - http://linuxhcl.com/

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-03 11:26
by dilberts_left_nut
Maybe an addition to auto-insert emoticons randomly through each post would be helpful too, for all of those who forget or don't want to.

:roll:

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-03 12:10
by ComputerBob
Personally, I don't care to post that much information about my systems in the signature of every post that I write, and I would prefer not to have to scroll past that much information about your system, over and over and over, in every thread in which you post.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-03 12:19
by squeezy
ComputerBob wrote:... I would prefer not to have to scroll past that much information about your system ...
That's why I turn signatures off in my forum preferences. Sometimes you can't tell the troubleshooting info from the signatures!

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-03 14:22
by ComputerBob
squeezy wrote:
ComputerBob wrote:... I would prefer not to have to scroll past that much information about your system ...
That's why I turn signatures off in my forum preferences. Sometimes you can't tell the troubleshooting info from the signatures!
It's too bad that someone would have to turn off everyone's signatures just because a few people insist on taking up so much space with theirs.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-03 15:16
by makh
The point was NOT TO ALTER THE SIGNATURE AREA .... but:

To have a button or tab to access this additional info, nothing more, nothing complicated. Nobody is forced to see it, until the tab or button is invoked. :idea:

One advantage shall be like: the scanner 2400 works, but @ colour mode and 75dpi doesnt performs.

Another: a compatible hp printer, it had issues. The other one ran perfect. Both ran, but run-time performance was different. :|

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-04 16:25
by yobo
Many times I try to find a solution for a problem that I have and the searching gets me to a linux user posting something like "in the machine that you can see in my signature ..." and of course you never know if that machine in his signature is the same machine he had when he posted.

Why should ever be a description of my machine in my signature? What is the point? In the 95% of a users posts the signature would be useless...

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-04 16:32
by makh
Hi Yobo

This has to be along the signature, NOT INSIDE SIGNATURE. :)

This is planned to be a contribution to open source :idea:

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-04 19:00
by ComputerBob
makh wrote:This is planned to be a contribution to open source :idea:
Judging from the responses in this thread so far, it doesn't look like this forum's users like your idea, so you're probably not going to find anyone here who will do the work to program it for you.

Maybe you'd like to contact the makers of this forum's phpBB software, and see if they'd like to implement your idea as a new forum feature in their software.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-04 19:06
by vbrummond
I also think if users wish to add this information they already can.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-04 20:12
by makh
Hi ComputerBob & vbrummond
ComputerBob wrote: ... so you're probably not going to find anyone here who will do the work to program it for you ...
GUI making softwares are very advanced these days. There shouldnt be any need to program/code. :)
vbrummond wrote: I also think if users wish to add this information they already can.
It is limited to 255 characters :!:

Its just a suggestion, the only intent is to benefit the opensource, nothing more.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-04 20:44
by ComputerBob
makh wrote:GUI making softwares are very advanced these days. There shouldnt be any need to program/code. :)
Then I look forward to seeing the results of your work on it.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-05 04:34
by makh
ComputerBob wrote:
makh wrote:GUI making softwares are very advanced these days. There shouldnt be any need to program/code. :)
Then I look forward to seeing the results of your work on it.
Respectively, the contribution here is merely a SUGGESTION. It is not an intend to become a forum designer. The current team is already doing an excellent job! :)

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-05 10:14
by Randicus
It all comes down to one factor: effort to usefulness/need ratio.

Effort
A dialogue listing several items that is displayed on demand would require at least a little work. Assuming of course, that php has an extension that allows such a thing. I have not perused all of their extensions, so I do not know if such a feature could be added.

Usefulness
People usually include their hardware and relevant software when asking a support question. Whether or not the new feature suggestion is a good idea, I doubt the demand for it would make it worth the effort to incorporate.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-05 12:50
by ComputerBob
makh wrote:
ComputerBob wrote:
makh wrote:GUI making softwares are very advanced these days. There shouldnt be any need to program/code. :)
Then I look forward to seeing the results of your work on it.
Respectively, the contribution here is merely a SUGGESTION. It is not an intend to become a forum designer. The current team is already doing an excellent job! :)
The people who designed and programmed this forum are the phpBB people, not this forum's administrators. So, if you're not willing/able to do the "easy, non-programming" work to make your suggestion come true, I suggest that you write to the phpBB people with your suggestion (a suggestion is not a "contribution") and see if they think that it would be worth it to do the work to include your suggestion in their forum software. I suspect that their response will be very similar to the ones that you've received here.

Re: Suggestion: An addition to signature

Posted: 2012-10-05 17:15
by makh
ComputerBob wrote:a suggestion is not a "contribution"
Respectively, your point is highly regarded.

It was suggested 3 years back to a friend, to try ubuntu. He failed to install. He was helped, ultimately linux kernel outshined window$. He is now a regular linux user. He contributes to the linux world by using, testing, feedback etc.

So,
Suggestion IS META-PHASE TO contribution
electron IS A WAVE AND A PARTICLE

a little off-topic...

Code: Select all

BE or NOT TO BE are two equivalent phases

A lad was suggested to look both sides of a road, and then cross it. He made it.
One who wasnt told, never made it back home. Suggestion TRANSFORMS INTO contribution.
One may disagree totally.